10 Most Disappointing Players of the 2024 College Football Season
As we approach the halfway mark of the 2024 college football season, it’s time to assess some players who have fallen short of expectations. The hype surrounding these athletes was palpable in the preseason, but their performances have left much to be desired.
1. **DJ Uiagalelei, QB, Oregon State**
After transferring from Clemson, expectations were sky-high for Uiagalelei. However, his struggles with accuracy and decision-making have hindered Oregon State’s offensive rhythm, leading to disappointing performances against ranked opponents.
2. **J.J. McCarthy, QB, Michigan**
The Wolverines’ quarterback was expected to take a leap in his development, but inconsistency has plagued his play. With a tendency to miss open receivers and costly turnovers, McCarthy’s growth has stagnated at a critical point in the season.
3. **Braelon Allen, RB, Wisconsin**
Coming off a strong previous season, Allen was anticipated to be a cornerstone of Wisconsin’s rushing attack. Instead, he has struggled to find running lanes and has been outperformed by younger backs, leading to a diminished role in the offense.
4. **Jordan Travis, QB, Florida State**
Travis was touted as a potential Heisman candidate, but injuries and inconsistent play have hampered his ability to lead Florida State. His struggles in the pocket and inability to make timely throws have left fans and analysts frustrated.
5. **Kool-Aid McKinstry, DB, Alabama**
Expected to be a lockdown corner and a key player for the Crimson Tide, McKinstry has been vulnerable in coverage, allowing big plays that have cost Alabama crucial games. His performance has not matched the lofty expectations set by his recruiting profile.
6. **Xavier Worthy, WR, Texas**
After a breakout season, Worthy was primed for a major year. However, inconsistent quarterback play and a lack of production have limited his impact. His inability to make game-changing plays has been a disappointment for Texas fans.
7. **Cameron Rising, QB, Utah**
Rising’s return from injury was highly anticipated, but he has struggled to regain his form. With a lack of mobility and timing issues with receivers, his season has not lived up to the promise shown in previous years.
8. **Jeremiah Trotter Jr., LB, Clemson**
Trotter was expected to anchor the Tigers’ defense, but he has struggled with missed tackles and coverage assignments. His inability to make key stops has raised questions about his readiness for the next level.
9. **Emeka Egbuka, WR, Ohio State**
Once viewed as a potential top target in a potent Ohio State offense, Egbuka has been overshadowed by other receivers and has struggled with drops and route running. His lack of production has been surprising given the talent surrounding him.
10. **J.T. Daniels, QB, Rice**
The veteran quarterback was looking for a resurgence after transferring, but inconsistent play has haunted him. He has struggled to adapt to a new system, resulting in poor decision-making and a lack of offensive cohesion.
10 Biggest Surprises of the 2024 College Football Season
On the flip side, several players have exceeded expectations and emerged as standout performers. Their contributions have been pivotal for their teams and have captured the attention of fans and scouts alike.
1. **Travis Hunter, WR/DB, Colorado**
Hunter’s dual-threat capability has made him one of the most electrifying players in college football. His ability to impact games on both sides of the ball has solidified his status as the top player in the nation, living up to the preseason hype.
2. **Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State**
The true freshman has made an immediate impact, showcasing elite speed and route-running skills. Smith’s emergence as a reliable target for his quarterbacks has been a pleasant surprise for the Buckeyes.
3. **Ryan Williams, WR, Alabama**
Another true freshman, Williams has stepped into a prominent role for the Crimson Tide. His explosiveness and knack for making big plays have quickly made him a key component of Alabama’s offense.
4. **Kaidon Salter, QB, Liberty**
Salter has taken the reins at Liberty and has performed beyond expectations. His strong arm and poise under pressure have helped elevate the Flames to unexpected heights this season.
5. **Malik Nabers, WR, LSU**
Nabers has emerged as a go-to receiver for the Tigers, consistently making tough catches and gaining critical yards. His chemistry with the quarterback has blossomed, making him a valuable asset in LSU’s high-powered offense.
6. **Jared Verse, DE, Florida State**
After a solid season last year, Verse has taken his game to another level, becoming a dominant force on the defensive line. His ability to pressure the quarterback and disrupt plays has made him a key player for the Seminoles.
7. **Dylan Gabriel, QB, Oklahoma**
Gabriel has embraced his role as the leader of the Sooners’ offense, showing significant improvement in his decision-making and accuracy. His ability to manage games and make crucial plays has exceeded preseason expectations.
8. **Omarion Miller, WR, Nebraska**
Miller has burst onto the scene as a true freshman, becoming a reliable target for the Cornhuskers. His big-play potential and ability to make contested catches have been a pleasant surprise for Nebraska fans.
9. **Xander Horvath, RB, Purdue**
Horvath has emerged as a breakout star for Purdue, showcasing impressive speed and vision. His ability to find the end zone consistently has revitalized the Boilermakers’ offense.
10. **J.J. Taylor, OL, Michigan State**
Taylor’s performance has been a revelation on Michigan State’s offensive line, providing stability and strong play in both run blocking and pass protection. His growth has been crucial for the Spartans’ success.
Conclusion
As the 2024 season approaches its midpoint, the narratives around these players highlight the unpredictability of college football. While some athletes have risen to the occasion, others have struggled to meet expectations. The second half of the season will be critical for both groups as they look to redefine their legacies in the sport.
