The New York Yankees’ $37 million, two-time All-Star is facing a critical juncture in his career. With his performance in decline, rumors are swirling that he could be on the move via trade this offseason. The player in question is none other than Giancarlo Stanton, who has been a central figure for the Yankees since his high-profile trade from the Miami Marlins in 2017. However, as his struggles have intensified, the Yankees may be forced to reconsider their investment in the power-hitting outfielder/designated hitter.
Stanton, whose contract runs through 2027 and includes a staggering $37 million salary in 2024, has been a key player in the Yankees’ lineup. His combination of raw power and ability to hit towering home runs made him one of the premier sluggers in baseball. However, the last few seasons have been marked by a series of injuries and declining production that have raised concerns about his future in the Bronx.
In 2023, Stanton struggled to stay healthy for much of the year. He missed a significant portion of the season with injuries, and even when he was on the field, his performance was inconsistent. Stanton posted a .212 batting average with 26 home runs and 61 RBIs, which represents a marked decline from his peak years. His power numbers, while still respectable, have been tempered by high strikeout rates and an inability to consistently make solid contact. Furthermore, his inability to play in the outfield regularly has limited his versatility, leaving him primarily as a DH.
For the Yankees, Stanton’s large contract and recent struggles are becoming an increasing burden. With a payroll already stretched thin and questions about the team’s overall direction, the club may look to move Stanton in an effort to free up financial space and build a more balanced roster. Trading Stanton would also help the team avoid the risk of further decline, as they could target players who are younger, healthier, and more in line with the Yankees’ long-term vision.
However, the question remains whether another team would be willing to take on Stanton’s contract, especially given his injury history and declining performance. While there is no doubt that Stanton still possesses immense power, teams will likely be cautious in acquiring him due to the potential financial commitment and the uncertainty surrounding his future health.
The Yankees will likely explore trade options for Stanton during the offseason, but any potential deal would require the team to either eat a portion of his salary or acquire players with contracts that align more favorably with their plans. Whether Stanton will remain in New York or be dealt elsewhere, his situation will be one of the most closely watched storylines of the winter.
