In a surprising turn of events for Alabama football, the 2024 All-American teams have been announced without any first-team selections from the Crimson Tide. For the third time since 2010, Alabama will not have a player named to the first-team All-American list, despite being a perennial powerhouse in college football. Three of Alabama’s standout players—Tyler Booker, Malachi Moore, and Ryan Williams—were recognized on the All-American lists, but all three were named to second- or third-team honors, a clear indication of the fierce competition for top spots in the nation.
Tyler Booker, a sophomore offensive lineman, earned recognition on the second-team All-American list by both the Associated Press (AP) and the American Football Coaches Association (AFCA). Booker has been a steady presence for Alabama’s offensive line this season, helping to protect quarterback Jalen Milroe and clear paths for the running game. His inclusion on the All-American teams is a testament to his growth and consistency at a key position on the team. Although many had hoped for Booker to be placed on the first team given his impact on the line, the high level of play from other top-tier offensive linemen in college football this year kept him out of that honor.
Malachi Moore, a junior safety, made appearances on the All-American lists as well, including second-team honors by the Walter Camp Football Foundation. Moore has been a leader on Alabama’s defense, playing a critical role in the secondary. His ability to cover ground quickly, read quarterbacks, and intercept passes has made him a key player for the Crimson Tide. Despite his strong performances and leadership, he was edged out by other standout defensive backs who dominated college football this season, which ultimately kept him from being a first-team selection.
Ryan Williams, the freshman wide receiver who has rapidly become one of the most exciting young talents in college football, was also named to an All-American list. Williams earned recognition on the third team from the AFCA, which highlights his remarkable potential and explosive playmaking ability. Williams’ performances as a true freshman, especially his ability to make critical catches in big moments, caught the attention of voters. However, given the depth and skill of wide receivers across the country, Williams found himself just short of a higher ranking on the list.
The absence of a first-team All-American from Alabama is noteworthy, as the Crimson Tide program has a long history of placing players on the prestigious first-team list. Alabama has often been home to some of the nation’s best talent, with countless players receiving high honors over the years. The last time Alabama failed to place a player on the first-team All-American list was in 2010, a year that saw the Tide’s defense and offense undergo significant changes. Since then, Alabama has had players like Derrick Henry, Tua Tagovailoa, and DeVonta Smith make first-team All-American honors.
This year, however, despite solid individual performances from Booker, Moore, and Williams, Alabama’s team fell short of producing a first-team All-American. The decision is a reminder that individual talent, while important, is often influenced by the overall competition and the context of the season. For Alabama, the lack of a first-team honoree does not take away from the strength and depth of its roster. The program continues to remain a dominant force in college football, and the future looks bright with young talents like Ryan Williams poised to lead the team for years to come.
