The 2025 MLB offseason has been filled with numerous player transactions and high-profile free-agent signings. Among the most closely watched negotiations is the expected battle for Tanner Scott, a hard-throwing left-handed reliever who has garnered significant attention due to his strong performances for the Miami Marlins in recent years. However, despite the interest from teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers and New York Mets, reports suggest that both teams may lose out on Scott’s services to an NL rival, potentially costing them $60 million in the process.
Scott has become one of the premier relievers in the league, known for his overpowering fastball and slider combination. His ability to generate strikeouts, combined with his effectiveness against left-handed hitters, has made him a coveted asset in a market that increasingly values bullpen strength. While the Dodgers and Mets have both been mentioned as suitors, other National League contenders are now seen as the favorites to secure his services.
The Dodgers, despite their perennial ability to sign top-tier talent, are navigating a unique offseason. With a high payroll already locked into place, they face financial constraints that limit their flexibility in the market. The team has been rumored to be focusing on securing high-end starting pitching and retaining key pieces of their roster, making it less likely that they would commit the $60 million that Scott is expected to command in a multi-year deal.
On the other hand, the Mets, now under the ownership of Steve Cohen, have made headlines for their aggressive spending in recent years. However, with a focus on improving their starting rotation and addressing some holes in their position player group, it appears that their bullpen may not be the immediate priority. Although they have been linked to Scott throughout the offseason, their potential interest might ultimately fall by the wayside as they shift resources toward other areas of need. Moreover, the Mets’ emphasis on rebuilding their farm system and future flexibility may result in them passing on a high-priced reliever like Scott.
Both teams, however, have been outbid by an unexpected contender from the National League: the Philadelphia Phillies. With their own payroll flexibility and a desire to further bolster a bullpen that has been shaky at times, the Phillies are poised to make a serious run at Scott. The team’s front office has indicated that they are willing to invest in bullpen depth, and Scott represents an ideal target. His strikeout rate and ability to get left-handed hitters out would provide a valuable weapon in the Phillies’ bullpen, particularly in high-leverage situations. Moreover, the team’s recent success in reaching the World Series, coupled with a strong core of players, positions them as a team capable of offering both competitive success and a lucrative deal.
For the Dodgers and Mets, missing out on Scott would be a setback, particularly as both teams look to stay competitive in their respective divisions. The loss could potentially cost them a significant boost to their bullpen, as well as the $60 million in potential value Scott could have added to their roster. However, with the nature of MLB free agency and the increasing importance of bullpen performance, both teams will undoubtedly turn their attention to other available options to strengthen their pitching staffs.
