The NFL’s Conundrum: Is Jeremiah Smith Ready to Make the Leap?
Jeremiah Smith, Ohio State’s phenomenal freshman receiver, has left the football world abuzz with his incredible debut season. The 19-year-old’s impressive performance has sparked a heated debate: is he ready for the NFL? Smith’s response to the question was telling – a mix of humility and confidence. “I definitely think I can [play in the NFL] for sure,” he asserted.
Smith’s talent is undeniable. He led the Big Ten in receiving and receiving touchdowns, breaking Cris Carter’s 40-year-old school freshman receiving record in the process. His performance has drawn comparisons to some of the greatest young players in college football history, including Adrian Peterson, Leonard Fournette, and Jadeveon Clowney.
However, the NFL’s eligibility rules require players to be three years removed from their high school graduation to be eligible for the draft. This means Smith would have to play two more college seasons before being eligible for the 2027 draft. The question is, should he be allowed to enter the draft earlier?
Those who have watched Smith play believe he is ready for the NFL. One NFL scout described him as “an immediate starter with a chance to become an impact player.” Mike Renner, a CBS Sports draft analyst, echoed this sentiment, saying Smith is “easily the best freshman wide receiver I’ve seen since I started scouting.”
But the NFL’s rules are in place to protect young players from entering the league before they are physically and emotionally ready. The league’s collective bargaining agreement with the NFL Players Association has maintained this requirement since 1990.
As Smith navigates the next two years, he will face immense pressure and scrutiny. His performance will be closely watched, and any misstep could impact his draft stock. The NFL’s rules may be designed to protect players like Smith, but they also create a challenging environment for those who are ready for the next level.
In the end, the decision to allow Smith to enter the draft earlier is a complex one. While his talent and maturity suggest he may be ready for the NFL, the league’s rules are in place to protect young players. As Smith continues to impress on the field, the debate surrounding his eligibility will only intensify.
