Mets Predicted to Part Ways with Pete Alonso, Eye All-Star Replacement
The New York Mets are reportedly preparing for a future without first baseman Pete Alonso, as the slugger is set to become a free agent after the 2025 season. Alonso, a four-time All-Star and the franchise’s all-time leader in home runs, has been a cornerstone of the Mets’ lineup since his 2019 debut. However, with the team’s evolving roster and financial considerations, the Mets are exploring potential replacements to maintain their competitive edge.
In February 2025, the Mets agreed to a two-year, \$54 million contract with Alonso, which includes an opt-out clause after the 2025 season. This deal allows Alonso to test the free-agent market, and given his impressive performance in a contract year—batting .333 with a .451 on-base percentage and a .646 slugging percentage—he is poised to attract significant interest from other teams .
Mets owner Steve Cohen has indicated that the team is focused on building a more robust competitive window beginning around 2025-26. While Cohen has expressed openness to re-signing Alonso, he also acknowledged that the first baseman’s impending free agency presents an opportunity for the Mets to explore other options . This strategic planning suggests that the Mets are preparing for the possibility of parting ways with Alonso.
If Alonso departs, the Mets have several potential replacements in mind. One option is Carlos Correa, a three-time All-Star currently with the Minnesota Twins. Correa, known for his defensive prowess and on-base skills, could provide stability at a corner infield position, though he is not a direct power-hitting replacement for Alonso .
Another possibility is Ryan Mountcastle of the Baltimore Orioles. At 27, Mountcastle offers a strong bat with an average of 26 home runs per 162 games. With two years remaining before arbitration, he could be a cost-effective option for the Mets to consider .
Additionally, Nolan Arenado of the St. Louis Cardinals has been mentioned as a potential trade target. Although Arenado is entering his age-34 season and has a substantial contract, the Mets’ financial flexibility could allow them to absorb his salary and benefit from his defensive excellence .
Should Alonso depart, his legacy with the Mets is secure. He ranks third in franchise history in slugging percentage, fifth in OPS, and fifth in home runs. His contributions have been instrumental in the Mets’ successes over the past several seasons. While the team explores future options, Alonso’s impact on the franchise remains undeniable.
The Mets are set to face the St. Louis Cardinals in a three-game series starting on Friday, May 2, 2025. Following that, they will travel to Arizona to play the Diamondbacks, with games scheduled through May 7. These upcoming matchups will be crucial as the Mets continue to evaluate their roster and plan for the future.
